Why does steve carell hate toby

He hates him because of what you just described. When they got married duh. One of the things that makes The Office such an amazing show to watch, aside from the talented cast, is the way it is shot. Angela Kinsey, who plays Angela Martin on the show, also had to deal with successfully hiding a pregnancy. Why is everyone so mean to Toby the office? Why was Michael Scott not fired? Does Micheal Scott get fired? Why was Michael Scott fired in Season 5?

Michael even mentions his birth father during an HR session with Toby, but is mostly reticent about what happened to him, and ultimately, he seems filled with resentment towards his mother and Jeff for changing his life so radically. Even in the aftermath of his divorce, Toby appears to be an involved and caring father, remaining a big part of his daughter Sasha's life, but it's possible that Michael harbors resentment for Toby for splitting up his family, reminding Michael of his own childhood trauma — which is to say nothing of the fact that Michael desperately wants a wife and kids, which Toby has seemingly given up.

As our intrepid Redditor points out, Michael's sense of subtlety and nuance is extraordinarily lacking, so he may conflate Toby's divorce with his own past in a way that makes him hate Toby with every fiber of his being.

Fans can theorize forever about why exactly Michael hates Toby, but according to Lieberstein, who also served as a writer and executive producer on the show, Carell came up with the bit right from the beginning. After an early episode where Toby steals the joke Michael was going to make on a coworker's birthday card in a scene that never even made it to air , Lieberstein explained the moment to The Daily Beast : "I just go in, write something quickly, and leave — that's the scene.

But it takes me a while to physically write it, and I could just feel him watching me, and feel that burning. Steve [Carell] told me afterwards that it was in that moment that he just decided to hate me so much. If you slip in any way, he pounces — just in a fun way, but it's embarrassing. Turns out Carell's instincts were right on the mark. Over years of Office marathons, fans have become obsessed with Michael's seemingly inexplicable hatred of Toby.

Throughout the show , Michael openly mocks Toby for being alone and divorced, threatens Toby's life, calls him names like "a waste" and an "evil snail," and wishes Toby would just die already. When Toby briefly leaves for Costa Rica, Michael is elated — but when he returns to the office shortly after, Michael absolutely loses it a moment that ultimately led to a classic meme.

Michael even goes so far as to say that if he had a gun with two bullets and he was in a room with Adolf Hitler, Osama Bin Laden, and Toby, he would "shoot Toby twice. It might seem like Michael is a bit over-the-top with his hatred of Toby, but it may also be true that Toby isn't exactly the best person in the office.

He can be overtly creepy — after harboring a longtime crush on Pam Jenna Fischer , he puts an unwelcome hand on her leg just before announcing his temporary move to Costa Rica — and lots of viewers think he might actually be the Scranton Strangler , a menacing presence mentioned throughout the series.